Eddie Marr
Officer Mulligan / Carpenter / Court Clerk / Bartender / Policeman / Gillen / Al...

Gene Lockhart
Innkeeper / Sir George / Evander Cobb / Samuel Fulton / David Keeney / O'Connor ...

James Mason
Self - Host

Dayton Lummis
/ Evans / Dr. Morrison / Col. Picquart / Captain McLandon / Bob Warren / Michae...

Edmond O'Brien
Rorsford / Hal / Harry 'Steve' Morgan / Randall / Maj. Jepelo / Mr. Protis / Mik...

Isobel Elsom
Mrs. Fishkettle / Mrs. Forbes / Miss Shoebridge / Ethel / Mrs. Scofield / Leonor...

Laraine Day
Lydia / Phyllis Dietrichson / Louise Howell / Charlotte Vale / Lynn / Sophie / C...

George Chandler
Fred / / Newspaper Man / Mr. Hollis / Eustace Peabody / Joe / Edgar

Phyllis Thaxter
Anne / Julie / Sister Mary / Connie Ennis / Diana Forbes / Fran / Karen

Ellen Corby
Nurse / Harriet / Norah / Aunt / / Lavinia Penniman / Martha

Thomas Mitchell
Johnny Reynolds

Johnny Reynolds

Fay Bainter
Innkeeper's Wife / Mrs. Hughes / Annie Keeney / Mrs. Grier

Robert Preston
Kelly / Tom / Phil Baxter / Jed Kennedy / Isaac Eaton / Dowey

Pat O’Brien
George Morrell / Eddie Gorman / Joe Crandall / Charley Hackett / Captain Barnaby...

Diana Lynn
Princess Maria / Singleton / Honor / Louise Franklin / Ruth Deeves / Ellen

Maureen O'Sullivan
Self - Intermission Guest / Intermission Guest / Mary / Agnes Fisher / Stella

Ruth Hussey
Harriet Craig / Meg / Irene / Kit Marlowe / Linda Carson / Polly Baxter

J. Pat O'Malley
London Bobby / Patrick / Griffin / Watkins / Richard / Alf

Anne Bancroft
Ann Sommers / Lolita / Sally / Cathy / Leah / Kendal Browning

Alexander Campbell
Judge Peabody / Walters / Mr. Winfield / Carrollman / Mr. Cheeley / Collins